Bringing you the "Good News" of Jesus Christ and His Church While PROMOTING CATHOLIC Apologetic Support groups loyal to the Holy Father and Church's magisterium
Home About
AskACatholic.com
What's New? Resources The Church Family Life Mass and
Adoration
Ask A Catholic
Knowledge base
AskACatholic Disclaimer
Search the
AskACatholic Database
Donate and
Support our work
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
New Questions
Cool Catholic Videos
About Saints
Disciplines and Practices for distinct Church seasons
Purgatory and Indulgences
About the Holy Mass
About Mary
Searching and Confused
Contemplating becoming a Catholic or Coming home
Homosexual and Gender Issues
Life, Dating, and Family
No Salvation Outside the Church
Sacred Scripture
non-Catholic Cults
Justification and Salvation
The Pope and Papacy
The Sacraments
Relationships and Marriage situations
back
Specific people, organizations and events
Doctrine and Teachings
Specific Practices
Church Internals
Church History


SoConfused wrote:

Hi, guys —

First of all, thank you for your help.

I am a Catholic. I was raised in a loving Catholic family and, against the better wishes of my parents, married a baptized Lutheran man who was twice divorced (one Protestant wedding and the other civil). I was not living according to my faith at the time we married.

We had, however, discussed his obtaining an annulment for his marriages. He agreed to follow through on the annulment procedure, but asked me to marry him before the annulment was obtained; he said that we would re-marry in the Church when it was possible. I agreed.

We were married and have been married for eleven years, however, soon after the marriage, my husband decided against the annulment process and it became a source of contention between us. Our marriage has not been an easy one. That being said, however, I am not looking for a reason to divorce him. Even though we were not married in the Church, I gave it much thought and still made my vows to God. Later in the marriage, I had reconciled that even though this marriage was not a good one, that I would keep my vows. We now have five children. I have experienced a strong conversion, repented, and firmly reattached myself to my faith to make up for the years of living outside the Church.

I had an opportunity through one of my groups, at Church, to request becoming a Eucharistic Minister. During the interview to initiate this process, it was explained to me that:

  • my marriage was not recognized by the Church, which I knew, and that would keep me from becoming a Eucharistic minister and
  • that I was also excommunicated.

This truly shook me as I have developed a true love of Jesus through this Sacrament and the thoughts of not being able to experience Jesus this way is crushing to me.

I talked with my husband and asked that he follow through with the annulment process. He became angry and said he refused to be pressured, becoming very angry at the Church.

I tried to explain it was my fault for going about things the wrong way, but it has turned him even further from the Church. Needless to say, I am totally at a loss as what to do. Given that my marriage to my husband has basically put me in a state of continual sin and my husband is not willing to move forward with me to repair this state, I do not know if I would be better off to divorce, or at least separate from, him and request an annulment myself since my marriage is not valid in the Church.

I can't see separating five children from their father as making God happy, but my living in continual sin surely is not what God wants from me either. Please help me. I truly cannot imagine going to Church for the rest of my life and not receiving Holy Communion. I don't want to live the rest of my life in disobedience to God's desire for me.

Please direct me as to what the Church would have me do in this situation.

God bless you for this ministry.
Please also pray for my children and this family.

SoConfused

  { How can I make my marriage and family right with the Church and in the eyes of God? }

Mary Ann replied:

Dear SoConfused,

You do need spiritual help, and expert help. You are rightly torn, and it appears that God is calling you. You must answer His call. It is at least, for now, a call to live celibately and lovingly in witness to the truth, and that witness may move and convince your husband. He will have the choice:

  • to separate or
  • to do what needs to be done for your sake and the sake of your union, if not for his own sake.

It seems that you have tried to make the decisions for everyone, and your husband has known that you would. You have to do things for God first, and it will work out for everyone, though it may take some witness, some suffering, and some time (as it is, you are experiencing all of those anyway, but to no good). It appears that your husband may have deceived you with a false promise at the time of your marriage, which would be grounds for annulment above and beyond whether your marriage was valid (due to form, or due to his previous marriages).

Your marriage is possibly invalid due to a number of factors:

  • if you were Catholic at the time, and married without a Church form or witness, and/or married a Protestant without a dispensation, then the marriage is invalid.
  • if you were not a Catholic, then the marriage may be invalid because your husband may have been still married to one of his previous partners.

It is not for anyone to say but the Tribunal. Please start inquiring about the process.

By the way, if your marriage isn't valid, it's not a bad marriage — it is not a marriage at all. The Church knows that someone baptized into the Body of Christ cannot marry outside the Body of Christ, cannot marry non-sacramentally, because our Baptismal conformation to Christ so defines us that any true marriage must be in Christ or it is not us! You have become close to Christ, and He has begun to guide you.

Another thing: you are not excommunicated. You are not able to receive Communion while in a state of sin, but that is different from excommunication.

You and your husband can try to live celibately together, and if you do, you may receive Communion; and if you fail at times, you can confess and receive Communion again. You are certainly permitted to stay together for the sake of the children, but it is under the condition of living as brother and sister until the previous unions of your partner are resolved one way or another.

God is calling you to something a bit difficult but with great payoffs. You are seeing all the worst things that might happen, and thinking that you are causing them, but that is not true. You only need to do the first basic thing God asks, and God will give your partner grace to respond. Perhaps with a struggle, but you can be at peace with your decision.

As for being an Extraordinary Minister, what you called Eucharistic Minister, that is a different case. The people in the parish will not know, as your pastor will know (you should tell him in Confession), that you will be living chastely with your partner during this interim period. For that reason, the pastor can admit you to Communion. No one should judge, but it is inevitable that people will take some scandal if they know about your marital situation and don't know that you are living chastely. The priest may decide to avoid scandal and not allow you to be a Eucharistic minister. Most of the trainers of ministers would not be aware of some of the subtle nuances here, so talk to the pastor. He can grant you permission to receive Communion as long as you live chastely and are working on a resolution.

If your husband loved you, he would want more than anything for you to be at peace with your conscience and with God. There are some things that must not be sacrificed for others, and among them is your conscience and your relationship with God. No good can come of it in the long run. The only good that comes is an apparent temporary peace that:

  • is artificial and
  • bought at the expense of the true welfare of all concerned.

Listen to the voice of Jesus. Give Him all, and He will respond and give it all back to you and more.

Mary Ann

Please report any and all typos or grammatical errors.
Suggestions for this web page and the web site can be sent to Mike Humphrey
© 2012 Panoramic Sites
The Early Church Fathers Church Fathers on the Primacy of Peter. The Early Church Fathers on the Catholic Church and the term Catholic. The Early Church Fathers on the importance of the Roman Catholic Church centered in Rome.