Matthew
wrote:
|
Hi, guys —
I am a 22-year-old male Catholic living in
Canada. I am currently in medical school,
and am in the hospital daily. I see death
and suffering nearly everyday. I am learning
to prevent suffering and prolong life as long
as possible. I have two questions:
- As a believer, I always thought suffering
was a necessary part of Christian life.
- Aren't we supposed to bear the wounds
of Christ?
- If so, are we expected to refuse medical
treatment that would make us feel better
and put a smile back on our face?
- Seeing death so often, made my
mind wonder: As a believer, we believe
death ultimately leads to Christ and eternal
happiness.
- If so, why use every possible tool to
prolong life?
- As weird as
it sounds, shouldn't we want to die?
- When we get sick and are on our death
bed, or get into a serious accident, shouldn't
we be jumping for joy because we know the
end is near: that we'll finally be with
our Lord in Heaven? (The shorter our time
on earth is, the better.)
If the answer to both questions is yes, especially
the second one:
- How can we be expected to enjoy life and
be joyful?
Not only must we choose to suffer voluntarily,
when help is available, but we should want
to wake up each morning hoping it's the day
we die. Rather then going after your dreams
and goals, we are taught not to get attached
to this world.
To me, that a little depressing: You live
longing for the day you die.
Thank you for helping me find the answers.
I am very, very grateful.
God bless,
Matthew
|
{
Shouldn't
we refuse medical treatment since death leads
to Christ and eternal happiness? }
|
John
replied:
Hi, Matthew —
Thanks for your question.
Let's see if we can't try and make
some sense of some confused theology.
First of all pain, suffering, sickness,
and disease, were never part of God's
plan. They entered the world when
man sinned. In doing so, man handed
over the earth to satan and hence
the curse of death, sickness, and
disease.
God doesn't inflict people with diseases.
If He did, He would be guilty of child
abuse. God is the author of Life.
Jesus came that we might have life
and have it more abundantly. satan
is the author of sin, sickness, and
disease.
That said, God allows these things
in the world and uses them for His
Divine Providence where satan intends
them for evil. Let me refer you to
the book of Job. God doesn't inflict
Job with suffering, satan does, with
God's permission. While satan
tries to use suffering to get Job
to curse God, God uses that suffering
to bring Job closer to Him.
Now against that background, let's
address the moral questions you posed.
We not required to use every means
necessary to prolong life. Rather,
we must (and I'll let others give
you the exact formula) use every
ordinary and reasonable mean keep
a person alive.
Returning to your question about
suffering: Christians are not supposed
to seek out suffering. Rather we
are suppose to deal with whatever
comes into our lives. Sometimes,
suffering is strictly an attack of
satan, meant to prevent us from fulfilling
God's call. God may be allowing this
in order to test our faith. By that
I mean, He expects us to rebuke satan
and look to God for healing so that
we might continue in the calling He
gave us. Other times, God allows
suffering in our lives so we can patiently
offer it up, united with His One,
Sacrifice on the Cross for our sanctification
and that of the world . . . but we shouldn't
be seeking suffering.
Since God made the human body, it
has a unique dignity. When it is
injured or sick, it is a holy thing
to try and heal it. Jesus went around
healing the sick. If suffering were
God's will, then Christ went against
His own will when He healed these
people.
Finally regarding death. God never
intended us to die. The only reason
we do die is because of original
sin but you make an interesting point.
As Christians, we have a joyful expectation
(or moral assurance) that when we
die, we will eventually be in Heaven
experiencing complete bliss.
St. Paul dealt with this struggle.
On a personal level, he thought it
would be better for him to be with
Christ, yet he also realized that
if he continued to live, he could
continue and finish the work God
had for him in His Divine Providence.
(Philippians 1:22-26)
So while we should always desire
to be close to the Lord, we shouldn't
wake up hoping to die every day.
John
|
Mary
Ann replied:
Matthew —
Suffering and death are part of Christian
life only in the sense that bearing
with Christ the unavoidable suffering
and death of this life is the path
of overcoming them. We are obliged
by the first commandment to honor
God, our Creator, the Lord of Life,
and we do this by respecting our
life.
We are obliged by the fifth commandment
to respect life: ours and that of
others. The
Church teaches we are morally obliged to take ordinary
care of our health. We are not obliged
to do extraordinary things to preserve
life or health.
Christianity does not canonize suffering
and death. They are evils, not part
of the original will of God. We brought
them into the world by sin. Christ
came to turn them into a means for
good,
if accepted as such, if accepted
in love. They are not to be desired
for their own sake, but when unavoidable,
they are to be accepted with patience
and love. It is the love that saves,
not the suffering. Even with Christ's
sacrifice, the sacrifice was His
obedience out of love, which was
expressed in His acceptance of all
the evils done to Him.
Mary Ann
|
Eric
replied:
Hi, Matthew —
Others have ably answered your first
question. As to your second question,
we should not want to die for several
reasons.
- For one, the more we develop our
relationship with God on Earth, the
more capacity we'll have for beatitude
(happiness, in earthly terms) in
the life to come.
- Second, perhaps related to that,
our reward in the life to come will
depend on what we do on Earth. If
you die now, you'll lose your opportunity
to gain more reward.
- Finally, God put us on Earth to work:
to be a light to the nations, to
spread the Gospel, to help other
people, and so forth. There is a
reason we don't go to Heaven immediately
upon Baptism.
Eric
[Related
Apostolic Letter]
|
|
|