|
 |
Angbarrientos
wrote:
|
Hi, guys —
I have a few questions about Catholicism.
- Why do Catholics pray to saints when
one of the Ten Commandments are:
8 You shall not make for yourself any
carved image, or any likeness of
anything that is in heaven above,
or that is in the earth beneath,
or that is in the water under the
earth; 9 you shall not bow down to
them nor serve them. For I, the Lord
your God, am a jealous God, visiting
the iniquity of the fathers on the
children to the third and fourth
generations of those who hate me, 10 but showing mercy to thousands, to
those who love Me and keep My commandments.
Deuteronomy 5:8-10
- Why do Catholics confess to a man, when
it is not necessary?
- Why don't Catholics read from the Bible
and teach the Congregation from the Scriptures?
- Why baptize a baby when a baby or small
child has no sin?
- Why do you believe they will be saved
from baptism automatically?
- Why can't a person without catechesis
receive the Eucharist?
- Why are priests called fathers and the
Pope called Holy Father, when Matthew 23:9 states:
9 And call no [man] your father upon the
earth: for one is your Father, which
is in Heaven.
In Scripture, the only Holy Father is Our
Lord. This title is not meant for any man.
I have more and more questions but all that
is taught in Catholicism is unbiblical and
even against God.
I believe so many people are confused in this
religion because 9 out of 10 Catholics can
never answer my questions.
Angbarrientos
|
{
Can you answer these questions that nine out of every
ten Catholics can't answer? }
|
Mike
replied:
Dear Angbarrientos,
We have answered most, if not all of
your questions, in our knowledge
base.
You may want to search for answers using it next time.
Nevertheless, I'll take the time
to answer your questions or at
least show you answers from our
database.
You said:
- Why do Catholics pray to saints when
one of the Ten Commandments are:
8 You shall not make for yourself any
carved image, or any likeness of
anything that is in heaven above,
or that is in the earth beneath,
or that is in the water under the
earth; 9 you shall not bow down to
them nor serve them. For I, the Lord
your God, am a jealous God, visiting
the iniquity of the fathers on the
children to the third and fourth
generations of those who hate me, 10 but showing mercy to thousands, to
those who love Me and keep My commandments.
Deuteronomy 5:8-10
- Why do Catholics confess to a man, when
it is not necessary?
I found these web postings in our database that should answer the previous two questions:
You said:
- Why don't Catholics read from the Bible
and teach the Congregation from the Scriptures?
Catholics are encouraged to read
from the Bible on a regular basis.
If there were more Catholics reading
the Bible, we would be a stronger
Church.
As far as teaching the congregation
goes, most, if not all, homilies or sermons that Catholics hear are based on the Scriptures for each specific day. We have two different cycles of Scripture readings:
- Catholics who faithfully attend Mass every Sunday hear the entire Bible over a three year period.
- Catholics who faithfully attend daily Mass hear the entire Bible over a two year period.
Even Sunday, Catholics hear
one reading from the Old Testament,
two readings from the New Testament
and one reading from the Gospel.
For each Mass a Catholic attends, the celebrant's job in to base his sermon on the Scripture readings for that day. He does this, or should do this, based on the guidance of the Teaching authority of the Church, the Magisterium. So the Church does teach the congregation from the Scriptures. If one reads the Scriptures without the proper context they can fall into the problem that St. Peter warned about in his second epistle:
20 First
of all you must understand this,
that no prophecy of scripture
is a matter of one's own interpretation, 21 because
no prophecy ever came by the impulse
of man, but men moved by the Holy
Spirit spoke from God.
2 Peter 1:20-21
The men moved by the Holy Spirit
are the priests of our Church who
have been trained to teach the Catholic
congregation from the Scriptures
they just heard for that Sunday.
I found these additional web postings in our database that should address any part of your question that I missed:
You said:
- Why baptize a baby
when a baby or small child has
no sin?
This posting should answer your question:
You said:
- Why do you believe
they will be saved from baptism
automatically?
This posting should answer your question:
You said:
- Why can't a person
without catechesis receive the
Eucharist?
These postings should answer your question:
You said:
- Why are priests called fathers and the
Pope called Holy Father, when Matthew 23:9 states:
9 And call no [man] your father upon the
earth: for one is your Father, which
is in Heaven.
These postings should answer your question:
You said:
In Scripture, the only Holy Father is Our
Lord. This title is not meant for any man. I have more and more questions but all that
is taught in Catholicism is unbiblical and
even against God.
This is not true. Jesus founded one
Church: the Catholic Church and this
can be historically proven. Any perception
that it is unbiblical or against
God is a distortion you have heard
from others.
You said:
I believe so
many people are confused in this
religion because 9 out of 10 Catholics
can never answer my questions.
This is an excellent point and probably the biggest problem we have in the
Church. For some reason, we are not
able to teach the Catholic Faith
correctly during the teenage years,
when most Catholics learn the faith.
This truly has to change to be what
Our Lord wants His Church to be.
Nevertheless, we have to remember
that bad or even scandalous behavior
in the Church has never taken away
from the Teachings Jesus taught Peter
and His Apostles. We don't leave
Peter, due to Judas behavior. To
this day, the Catholic Church is
the only Church that has safeguarded
and preserved all of His (Jesus') Teachings.
We have never added new teachings,
though we may have clarified them.
You may find my Scripture Passages
web page interesting. It scripturally defends Catholic doctrines and teachings.
A Biblical defense for Catholic teachings
https://www.AskACatholic.com/ScripturePassages
I hope this helps and that you feel that you have
finally met a Catholic that has answered
all your questions. :
)
I know these postings make up a lot
of reading, but if you really want
to understand what Catholic Christians
believe and who we are, you'll read
everything . . . and pick up a copy of the Catechism of the Catholic Church.
Take care,
Mike
|
Angbarrientos
replied:
Hello . . .
and thank you for your response
to my questions about the Catholic
Faith.
I have read the responses and I
must admit that they are even more
confusing than ever.
When I said:
I believe so
many people are confused in this
religion because 9 out of 10 Catholics
can never answer my questions.
Mike replied:
This is an excellent
point and probably the biggest problem
we have in the Church. For some reason,
we are not able to teach the Catholic
Faith correctly during the teenage
years, when most Catholics learn
the faith. This truly has to change
to be what Our Lord wants His Church
to be.
In reference to my second question
on Confession to a priest, Scripture
still states:
5 For there is one God and
one Mediator between God and men,
the Man Christ Jesus, 6 who gave
Himself as a ransom for all.
1 Timothy 2:5-6
Jesus said to him:
6 I am the Way, the Truth
and the Life. No one comes to
the Father but by Me.
John 14:6
37 the one who comes to Me,
I will by no means cast out.
John 6:37
It is in the Scriptures. No other
explanation or justification for
Confession is needed. There
is no confusion in these words. Like
all the questions I asked, the answers
are all in the Bible. There is no
gray, just black and white.
I was a Catholic and, with all due
respect, I was never filled with
the Word. As a matter of fact,
I didn't know who the Lord was until
I started reading the Scriptures,
then it made sense. I do not believe
that the Word of God should be confusing.
When I only read
from the Scriptures, I finally realized
how I was suppose to live my life,
not as tradition.
Looking back at Catholic doctrine,
it is their way, or no way. I have
found the Catholic Church is judgmental
and intolerant. The Lord is not.
When I gave my life to the Lord,
as a sinner that
I am, the Lord started to change me.
It wasn't because I went to:
- Catechism classes
- Mass, or
- confessed my sins to a man.
I never opened a Bible because we
weren't supposed to read from the
Bible.
It was, and is, what the Lord wants
us to know. Nonetheless, if the Catholic
faith cannot teach the Word of God
correctly, as stated above, maybe
is because they are not teaching
correctly from the Bible, something people
need to know; that would be my guess.
I believed you have answered all
my questions which leaves me to believe
I have made the right decision in
my walk with Christ!
Angbarrientos
|
Eric
replied:
Dear Angbarrientos —
Sorry to be late to the party here
but I have a few things to add.
There are a few key verses here.
One is John 20:22-23:
22 And with that he breathed
on them and said, 'Receive
the Holy Spirit. 23 If you forgive
anyone's sins, their sins
are forgiven; if you do not forgive
them, they are not forgiven.'
Jesus is speaking to the Apostles
and this is only the second time
God breathed on a man
(the first was when man was created).
Jesus is giving them the power to
forgive sins and in order to forgive
sins, and judge whether they are
to be forgiven or retained. To do this they
have to hear what the sins are.
Confession of sins should not be
a surprise to you. James 5:16 calls
on us to confess our sins to one
another.
- Does your church do this?
Clearly, God is not calling us to
only confess them to Him privately,
if he commands us to confess them
to one another! God ordained Confession
as a way of humbling ourselves and
keeping ourselves accountable to
men.
The verses before this one, verses 14-15, (all verses: James 5:14-16), demonstrate that the
priests, (priest comes
from the Greek word presbyter, sometimes
translated elder), have
the power to forgive sins. In this
particular case, the context is the
sacrament of Anointing of the Sick,
not Confession, but it establishes
that forgiveness of sins is a power
Christ gave to men.
St. Paul alludes to this ministry
of reconciliation in 2 Corinthians
5:19-20, where he says that Christ
reconciled the world to himself and
19 . . . committed to us the message
of reconciliation. Therefore we
are Christ's ambassadors, as though
God were making his appeal through
us.
This is precisely an illustration
of the way in which the priest shares
in the mediation of Christ,
as we all do in various ways. As
others pointed out, even evangelism
is a form of mediating in that we
attempt to reconcile people to God
by bringing them together.
Catholics believe that only, what
we call mortal sins, — murder,
adultery, apostasy, other sexual
sins that are done deliberately and
knowingly — must be confessed
in this sacrament, although we do
believe that the sacrament provides
grace for lesser sins. This illustrates
a point: Paul says that there is
a connectedness between members of
the body of Christ:
26 If one part suffers, every
part suffers with it; if one part
is honored, every part rejoices
with it. (1 Corinthians
12:26)
This applies to sin as well, as it
did in the Old Testament: When one
member sins, the whole body is affected,
just as when one part of your body
is injured, the whole body is affected.
When you sin grievously, it is not
just a matter between you and Jesus.
It's between you, Jesus, and His
Body, the Church. Therefore, you
must be reconciled to the Body through
the priest.
Eric
|
Mike
replied:
Dear Angbarrientos —
You said:
When I gave my life to the Lord,
as a sinner that I am, the Lord started to changed me.
It wasn't because I went to:
- Catechism classes
- Mass, or
- confessed my sins to a man.
I never opened a Bible because we
weren't supposed to read from the
Bible.
It was, and is, what the Lord wants
us to know.
It is truly sad that you
have been given the impression that
reading the Scriptures privately
is of little importance.
As I said earlier:
As far as teaching the congregation
goes, most, if not all, homilies or sermons that Catholics hear are based on the Scriptures for each specific day. We have two different cycles of Scripture readings:
- Catholics who faithfully attend Mass every Sunday hear the entire Bible over a three year period.
- Catholics who faithfully attend daily Mass hear the entire Bible over a two year period.
Even Sunday, Catholics hear one reading from the Old Testament, two readings from the New Testament and one reading from the Gospel.
For each Mass a Catholic attends, the celebrant's job in to base his sermon on the Scripture readings for that day. He does this, or should do this, based on the guidance of the Teaching authority of the Church, the Magisterium.
Now:
- if the homilies were not inspiring
enough to change your life, or
- CCD classes were poorly taught
for that I apologize but like I said earlier:
We don't leave
Peter, due to Judas behavior.
My question is whether there is something you have not mentioned that is behind your questions. When someone
replies like this, there are usually other moral issues that are being
evaded for some reason.
The sacraments of the Church are
the Divine Dynamite that powers our faith and love for the Church, yes, with all its failings and shortcomings.
Hope this helps,
Mike
|
|
|
|