Hi Sandra,
Thanks for your question.
To what Bob wrote, I'd like to add
the following.
Most Christians hold that the Church
was born on Pentecost, 33 A.D., when
the Holy Spirit descended on Mary
and the Apostles. For us as Catholics,
we would consider this to be the
founding of the Catholic Church.
However the reason that Protestants
do not recognize that the Catholic
Church is the first Church is because
they do not associate the "Catholic
Church" with the Church started
at Pentecost. In other words, they
do not believe that the organization
today known as the Catholic Church
is the same body of believers that
started at Pentecost. (Interesting
factoid, though: the first use of
the term "catholic" is
in 110 A.D., where St. Ignatius of
Antioch, a martyr later thrown to
the lions, wrote to a church in Asia
Minor,
"Where the bishop is,
there let the people gather; just
as where ever Jesus Christ is, there
is the Catholic Church."
St. Ignatius of Antioch |
Instead,
Protestants typically believe that
the "Catholic Church" started
at some vaguely defined point of
time much later in history, for example,
in the fourth century. In part, this
is because today's Catholic Church
has more of an external resemblance
to the historical church of the fourth
century than it does to the popular
image of the first century Church.
It's very tempting to believe
that the Church of Pentecost can't
be the Catholic Church, that the
Catholic Church arose at a later
time.
While it's undeniable that the first
century Church looked very different
from the fourth century Church (or
today's Catholic Church), this does
not imply that they are different
churches, for it is just as undeniable
that the infant looks very little
like the adult even though they are
in fact the selfsame person. Or,
again, it is undeniable that an acorn
looks nothing like an oak tree, but
all oak trees developed from tiny
acorns. Likewise, the Catholic Church
started in seminal form on Pentecost
and developed over time into the
form we see today.
The key question is whether the beliefs
are consistent across that period
of time.
- Did the early Church in
belief resemble more the Catholic
Church or the Protestant church?
If you look at the historical
records, such as the writings of:
you'll find
that early Church beliefs are
indeed consistent with the teachings
of the Catholic Church today on
issues such as the roles and authority
of priests and bishops, the Eucharist,
Confession, Baptism, and so forth.
Another factor is the succession
of bishops which go all the way back
to the Apostles. This proves that
the Catholic Church today is the
church of the Apostles. The more
you study the history of the early
Church, the clearer the Catholic
Church stands out as the Church
of the Apostles, upholding Apostolic
teaching. Unfortunately, being well-versed
in history has not historically been
a strong suit for Protestantism,
which may be another reason why they
don't associate the Catholic Church
with the early Church.
I hope this answers your question.
May God bless you in your quest for
the truth, and give you the desire
of your heart.
Yours in Christ,
Eric Ewanco
|