Bringing you the "Good News" of Jesus Christ and His Church While PROMOTING CATHOLIC Apologetic Support groups loyal to the Holy Father and Church's magisterium
Home About
AskACatholic.com
What's New? Resources The Church Family Life Mass and
Adoration
Ask A Catholic
Knowledge base
AskACatholic Disclaimer
Search the
AskACatholic Database
Donate and
Support our work
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
New Questions
Cool Catholic Videos
About Saints
Disciplines and Practices for distinct Church seasons
Purgatory and Indulgences
About the Holy Mass
About Mary
Searching and Confused
Contemplating becoming a Catholic or Coming home
back
Homosexual and Gender Issues
Life, Dating, and Family
No Salvation Outside the Church
Sacred Scripture
non-Catholic Cults
Justification and Salvation
The Pope and Papacy
The Sacraments
Relationships and Marriage situations
Specific people, organizations and events
Doctrine and Teachings
Specific Practices
Church Internals
Church History


Lon Grassman, Ph.D. wrote:

Hi guys,

I was born and baptized Roman Catholic in France but rarely attended church until my adulthood. I do recall doing something at around age 10.

  • Could this have been Confirmation?

Other than that, we never attended church.

Three years ago, I began attending an Episcopalian church and was confirmed.

  • If I want to return to the Catholic Church, what steps are involved?
  • Aren't I already a Catholic by birth?

Thanks!

Lonnie Grassman, Ph.D.
Kingsville, Texas

  { If I was Catholic but am now an Episcopalian, what steps are needed to return to the Church? }

Eric replied:

Hi Lonnie,

Basically, you go to Confession, confessing your separation and absence from the Church and any other grave sins you can recall since then. In some rare cases, depending on what you did apart from the Church [for example, if you became a minister in another denomination] you may need to make a public profession of faith but the priest will instruct you appropriately.

Then you are home! Welcome!

Depending on your level of education in the faith, you may want to embark on a program of study of some sort, for example, reading the Catholic Catechism, or attending the local parish's RCIA classes (though you wouldn't enroll in RCIA yourself).

You may find this site a good bedrock of resources:

CatholicsComeHome.org

Eric

Richard replied:

Dear Dr. Grassman,

My colleague Eric has already sent a response while I drafted this, but I'll send it along just the same. You are indeed already a Catholic, since you were baptized in a Catholic church.

Returning to Catholic life is easy enough: you can simply start attending Mass on Sundays (or Saturday evening, if you like); and before you start to receive Holy Communion, you should probably make a general confession covering the years while you were away from the Church.
You may choose any priest you wish for this.

Eventually, it would be a good thing to establish that you were confirmed. If you were not confirmed at age ten, you can be confirmed now. The Catholic Church does not recognize Episcopalian bishops as able to confer the sacrament validly, so the rite you received as an Episcopalian would not be counted.

Your parish priest will probably have to contact the diocese in France where you lived so that someone can check the parish records.

By the way, in case you are interested, there is a congregation of former Episcopal Church members in Corpus Christi who are now Catholics. They have permission to celebrate Mass with much of the beautiful Anglican traditional forms preserved.

They have a web page at:

There are several such congregations in the United States, and by coincidence most of them are in Texas.

  • Our Lady of Walsingham Catholic Church - Houston, Texas
    We are the Principal Church for the Personal Ordinariate of the Chair of St. Peter established by the Holy Father to restore the Anglican Patrimony to the Catholic Church.

God bless!

— Richard Chonak
for AskACatholic.com

John replied:

Lonnie,

It's wonderful that you that you want to come home.

If you were indeed confirmed at 10, Eric is correct, the only sacramental requirement is Confession.

It could also be that sacrament you received at 10 was simply First Holy Communion. You'll have to probe your memory and perhaps try to find some records.

If you were never confirmed, confirmation in the Episcopal Church is not considered valid because they did not retain Apostolic Succession.

You may be required to be confirmed, perhaps conditionally, if only your Confirmation is in doubt. In this case, RCIA would be a requirement.

I would highly recommend a good RCIA program either way. You should understand what you are committing to.

I join Eric in welcoming you home!

John D.

Mary Ann replied:

Lonnie,

Although you were baptized a Catholic, it sounds as though you were not catechized at all, and probably don't know your faith. You probably didn't have any idea you were doing anything wrong when you were confirmed in the Episcopalian Church. If you had no idea, then you did nothing sinful.

My colleagues are right to say that returning is simple:

  • a matter of a profession of faith and
  • maybe receiving Reconciliation, the Eucharist, and Confirmation for the first time.

The parish in France can tell you if you have received any of those sacraments. Confirmation in the Episcopal Church is, of course, non-sacramental because the true episcopacy is lacking. If you haven't received certain sacraments, then some instruction would be called for.

Meanwhile, I would suggest to read the Catechism, and to talk to your local pastor.

God bless!

Mary Ann

Richard followed-up:

Dear Professor,

I forgot to mention one more issue: marriage! I'm not married yet, so I always forget this.

If you happen to be married, please discuss it with your pastor to make sure that your marriage is already valid under Church law. Numerous variables enter into this:

  • whether your wife is also a baptized Christian,
  • whether this is a first marriage for both of you,  and so on.

With regards —

— Richard Chonak

Lonnie replied:

Dear Richard:

Regarding marriage and my wife: We were married 12 years ago, me, as a non-practicing Catholic, and she, as a Buddhist (my wife is Thai). In fact, we were married in a Catholic church, by a Catholic priest, with Catholic protocols, in the USA but of course, this marriage was not sanctioned by the Archdiocese. My wife was baptized as an Episcopalian two years ago.

  • Where does this leave us in terms of our marriage and in terms of her becoming a Catholic as well?

Regarding our children: they (two girls, aged 6 and 9) were baptized as babies in a Catholic Church in Bangkok, Thailand. Since then, they have attended the Episcopalian church, have received communion, etc., but have not participated in any other passages of rites such as confirmation, etc. due to their age. My eldest daughter is an Acolyte (the equivalent of an altar boy).

Thank you all for your responses to date. This has all been very helpful!

By the way, I am very interested in attending a retreat at a Trappist (Roman Catholic) Abbey someday to participate in the prayers, the chants of the monks, and really get to experience their lives. New Melleray Abbey in Iowa and Abbey of Gethsemane in Kentucky are the two I am most interested in.

  • Can anyone offer any insights?

Thank you,

Lon
Lon Grassman, Ph.D.
Kingsville, TX

Eric replied:

Lon,

I'm confused:

  • If it was in a Catholic church by a Catholic priest with Catholic protocols, why was it not sanctioned by the archdiocese?

If it's a Catholic priest following Catholic protocols, it would have to be sanctioned by the diocese in which you were married.

  • Was it a jurisdictional issue, i.e., you were non-U.S. citizens visiting the U.S. and thus could not get married in the U.S.? (I'm not sure what the rules are here.)

Eric

Richard replied:

Hi, Professor,
Hi, Eric,

The default rule on mixed marriages provides that a Catholic normally cannot marry a non-Catholic; however, this rule can be waived if the bishop grants a dispensation, and it's a routine matter.

It sounds as if the priest chose not to seek that dispensation. Maybe he thought he was doing you a favor by expediting things, but I'd consider it a mistake on his part.

While an unauthorized mixed marriage of a Catholic and another Christian can be valid under Church law, that is not the case for an unauthorized mixed marriage of a Catholic and a non-Christian.

Since your wife was a non-Christian at the time of the wedding, then the status of your marriage will need to be set right as part of your return to normal Catholic life. You and your local pastor can arrange for whatever is necessary, so the next good step is to find a time to meet with him, and go from there.

With regards —

— Richard Chonak

Please report any and all typos or grammatical errors.
Suggestions for this web page and the web site can be sent to Mike Humphrey
© 2012 Panoramic Sites
The Early Church Fathers Church Fathers on the Primacy of Peter. The Early Church Fathers on the Catholic Church and the term Catholic. The Early Church Fathers on the importance of the Roman Catholic Church centered in Rome.